Compare Mini Roadster R59 vs Mini F57 vs Volkswagen Beetle A5 Cabriolet

Mini Roadster R59

Mini F57

Volkswagen Beetle A5 Cabriolet

Mini Roadster R59Mini F57Volkswagen Beetle A5 Cabriolet
Variants
Cooper
Cooper AT
Cooper S
Cooper S AT
Cooper SD
Cooper SD AT
Cooper
Cooper AT
Cooper D
Cooper D AT
Cooper S
Cooper S AT
Cooper SD AT
JCW
JCW AT
One
1.2 TSI
1.2 TSI DSG
1.4 TSI
1.4 TSI DSG
2.0 TDI 110
2.0 TDI 110 DSG
2.0 TDI 150
2.0 TDI 150 DSG
2.0 TSI
2.0 TSI DSG

Reviews

Neofiliac score13%27%39%
Pros
  • Decent handling
  • Improved exterior quality
  • Improved interior quality
  • Rather good styling
  • Improved performance
Cons
  • Very, very ugly
  • No powerful engine options
  • Only available with small engines
  • Stuck with MacPherson struts in the front
  • Low cargo capacity
  • Even smaller engines
  • Stuck with MacPherson struts in the front
  • Low cargo capacity
  • Inline-3 and diesel in a convertible
  • No independent rear suspensions
  • Only available with small engines
  • Lingering reliability concerns

Price

Offers (incl. referral links)
RemoveRemoveRemove
Add up to 3 products to the comparison using the search bar above
Information on this page is provided on a best effort basis. This page may contain affiliate links to third-party merchants such as Amazon and eBay. If you make a purchase using the supplied link, we may receive a commission. Neofiliac respects your privacy. We do not track your activity on this website.