Compare BMW X5 M G05 vs BMW X3 M F97 vs BMW X1 E84 LCI

Variants
X5 M
X5 M Competition
X3 M
X3 M Competition
sDrive16d
sDrive16d AT
sDrive18d
sDrive18d AT
xDrive18d
xDrive18d AT
sDrive18i
sDrive18i AT
sDrive20d EffcientDynamics
sDrive20d
sDrive20d AT
xDrive20d
xDrive20d AT
sDrive20i
sDrive20i AT
xDrive20i
xDrive20i AT
xDrive25d
xDrive25d AT
xDrive28i
xDrive28i AT

Capacity

Cargo Capacity
580 L / 20.5 cu-ft ~ 1530 L / 54.0 cu-ft
550 L / 19.4 cu-ft ~ 1600 L / 56.5 cu-ft
420 L / 14.8 cu-ft ~ 1350 L / 47.7 cu-ft
Engine Oil Capacity
10.0 L / 10.6 qt
7.0 L / 7.4 qt
Fuel Capacity
83.0 L / 21.9 gal
65.0 L / 17.2 gal
Passengers
5
5
5
Payload
705 kg / 1554 lbs
530 kg / 1168 lbs

Chassis

Brakes | Front
Ventilated discs
Ventilated discs
Ventilated discs
Brakes | Rear
Ventilated discs
Ventilated discs
Ventilated discs
Power Steering
Electric Steering
Electric Steering
Suspension | Front
Double-wishbone
Double-wishbone
MacPherson strut
Suspension | Rear
Multi-link
Multi-link
Multi-link
Turning Circle
12.8 m / 42.0 ft
12.6 m / 41.3 ft

Construction

Body Style
5-door SUV
5-door Crossover
5-door Crossover

Dimensions

Ground Clearance
213 mm / 8.4 in
Size | Height
1545 mm / 60.8 in
Size | Length
4938 mm / 194.4 in
4726 mm / 186.1 in
4477 mm / 176.3 in
Size | Width
2015 mm / 79.3 in | 2218 mm / 87.3 in (mirror unfolded)
1798 mm / 70.8 in
Track Width | Front
1699.0 mm / 66.9 in
1500.0 mm / 59.1 in
Track Width | Rear
1688.0 mm / 66.5 in
1602.0 mm / 63.1 in
1529.0 mm / 60.2 in
Weight
2295.0 kg / 5059.6 lbs
1970.0 kg / 4343.1 lbs
Wheelbase
2972 mm / 117.0 in
2864 mm / 112.8 in
2760 mm / 108.7 in

Performance

CO2 Emission
284 ~ 289 g/km
239 g/km
Coefficient Of Drag
0.37
0.36
Fuel Economy
12.5 L/100km / 18.8 MPG (combined) | 16.8 L/100km / 14.0 MPG (urban) | 9.5 L/100km / 24.8 MPG (highway)
Top Speed
250.0 km/h / 155.3 mph
250.0 km/h / 155.3 mph
Towing Capacity
750 kg / 1653 lbs (w/o brakes) | 3000 kg / 6614 lbs (w/ brakes @ 12% gradient)
750 kg / 1653 lbs (w/o brakes) | 2500 kg / 5512 lbs (w/ brakes @ 12% gradient)

Powertrain

Drivetrain Layout
Front-engine (longitudinal), All-wheel drive
Front-engine (longitudinal), All-wheel drive
Emission Standard
Euro 6d-TEMP
Euro 6d-Temp
Engine
S58B30
Engine | Bore
89.0 mm / 3.5 in
84.0 mm / 3.3 in
84.0 mm / 3.3 in
Engine | Compression Ratio
10.0:1
9.3:1
Engine | Displacement
4.4 L / 268.2 cu-in / 4395.0 cc
3.0 L / 182.6 cu-in / 2993.0 cc
Engine | Stroke
88.3 mm / 3.5 in
90.0 mm / 3.5 in
Engine | Type
Twin-scroll turbocharged direct-injected petrol V8 engine with 4 values per cylinder
Twin-scroll turbocharged direct-injected petrol inline-6 engine with 4 values per cylinder
Fuel Capacity
83 L
Transmission | Gears
8-speed
8-speed
Transmission | Type
Automatic Steptronic
Automatic Steptronic

Production

Availability
2019
2019
2012 ~ 2015
Debut
2019-10-01
Made In
USA

Reviews

Neofiliac score
71%
74%
28%
Pros
  • Great performance
  • Excellent styling
  • Good handling
  • Good towing capacity
  • Superb S58 twin-turbo I6 engine
  • Spotless styling
  • New ZF 8HP automatic transmission
  • Good manual transmission
  • Decent styling for a crossover
  • RWD widely available
Cons
  • Crossover nonsense
  • High 0.37 drag coefficient
  • Questionable reliability
  • High 0.36 drag coefficient
  • Why not buy an M3?
  • Horrible engine reliability
  • MacPherson front suspension

Price

Offers (incl. referral links)
Remove
Remove
Remove
Add up to 4 products to the comparison using the search bar above
Information on this page is provided on an as-is basis. No warranty on accuracy is implied. This page may contain affiliate links to third-party merchants such as Amazon and eBay. If you make a purchase using the supplied link, we may receive a commission. Neofiliac places the utmost respect for your privacy. We use no cookie whatsoever beyond that needed for the proper functioning of the website.