Compare Mercedes-Benz SL R231 vs Mercedes-Benz S-Class Cabriolet A217 vs BMW M8 F91

Mercedes-Benz SL R231

Mercedes-Benz S-Class Cabriolet A217

BMW M8 F91

Mercedes-Benz SL R231Mercedes-Benz S-Class Cabriolet A217BMW M8 F91
Variants
SL 63 AMG 537
SL 63 AMG 585
SL 65 AMG
SL 350
SL 400
SL 500
S 63 AMG 4MATIC
S 65 AMG
S 500
Maybach S 650
M8
M8 Competition

Reviews

Neofiliac score97%96%87%
Pros
  • New, more reliable engine lineup
  • New, better electronics
  • Good, athletic styling
  • Great, opulent styling
  • Decent build quality
  • Powerful engine lineup without tiny weasels
  • Last chance to get V12 from Merc
  • Rather good performance
  • Powerful V8 (perhaps the last from BMW)
  • Decent handling
  • Luxurious interior
Cons
  • Uglier than R230
  • No more SL600
  • ABC is better but still unreliable
  • V12 married to MBC
  • S63 AMG limited to AWD
  • Poor ride comfort
  • Reliability concerns

Price

Offers (incl. referral links)
RemoveRemoveRemove
Add up to 3 products to the comparison using the search bar above
Information on this page is provided on a best effort basis. This page may contain affiliate links to third-party merchants such as Amazon and eBay. If you make a purchase using the supplied link, we may receive a commission. Neofiliac respects your privacy. We do not track your activity on this website.