Compare Samyang 12mm F2.8 ED AS NCS Fisheye vs Tokina AT-X 10-17mm F3.5-4.5 DX Fisheye vs Tokina atx-i 11-20mm F2.8
Variants
EF-mount
F-mount
Construction
Aperture Blades
7 blades, Circular blades
6 blades
9
Colors
Black
Black
Black
Form Factor
Ultra Wide-Angle Prime Lens
Ultra Wide-Angle Zoom Lens
Image Size
Full-Frame
APS-C
APS-C
Lens Barrel
Physical aperture ring, Distance scale
Distance scale, DoF scale
Lens Mount
Canon EF-mount, Nikon F-mount, Pentax K-mount, Sony A-mount, Sony E-mount
Canon EF-mount, Nikon F-mount
Canon EF-mount, Nikon F-mount
Motor
Screw drive from camera
Silent-Drive focusing Motor (SD-M)
Optical Formula | Elements
12 elements
10 elements
14 elements
Optical Formula | Groups
8 groups
8 groups
12 groups
Optical Formula | Special Glass
2 aspherical, 3 ED, nano coating system groups
SD element groups
Dimensions
Filter Diameter
82 mm
Size | Diameter
77 mm / 3.03 in
70 mm / 2.76 in
89 mm
Size | Length
73 mm / 2.87 in
71 mm / 2.80 in
Weight
515 g / 18.20 oz
350 g / 12.37 oz
Function
Angle Of View
180° Diagonal (fisheye)
180° Diagonal ~ 100° Diagonal (fisheye)
104°-72°
Aperture
f/2.8 ~ f/22
f/3.5–4.5 ~ f/22
F/2.8 - f/22
Autofocus
No
Yes
Crop Factor
1.5
Focal Length
12 mm
10 mm ~ 17 mm
11-20 mm
Focal Length (35mm Equivalent)
15.0 mm ~ 25.5 mm
16-30mm
Focus Type
Internal
Extending front
Image Stabilization
No
No
Weather Resistance
No
No
Zoom Type
Internal Zoom
Performance
Max Magnification
1:8.62
Min Focus Distance
200 mm / 7.87 in
140 mm / 5.51 in
0.28 m
Production
Accessory
Lens hood included
Lens Hood: built-in hood (supplied)
Lens Hood: BH-821
Availability
2020-07-10
Debut
2014-11-01
2011-06-12
2020-06-18
Made In
Japan
Reviews
Neofiliac score
40%
31%
Pros
- 180° FOV
- Reasonably good sunstar
- Unique fisheye zoom
- Reaches 180° FOV
- Ultra-wide angle of view.
- Bright f/2.8 aperture.
- Dust and splash protection.
Cons
- Lacks front filter thread
- Lacks weather sealing
- Not the sharpest
- Lacks front filter thread
- Not the highest build quality
- Expensive.
- Omits fluorine protection.
Remove
Remove
Remove
Add up to 4 products to the comparison using the search bar above
Information on this page is provided on an as-is basis. No warranty on accuracy is implied. This page may contain affiliate links to third-party merchants such as Amazon and eBay. If you make a purchase using the supplied link, we may receive a commission. Neofiliac places the utmost respect for your privacy. We use no cookie whatsoever beyond that needed for the proper functioning of the website.